Summary of the 2009
Lake Vermilion Creel Survey
MN DNR Fisheries


The Minnesota Dept. of Natural Resources, Section of Fisheries, conducted a creel survey on Lake Vermilion in 2009, as part of the statewide Large Lake Program. Creel survey is a scientific method of estimating fishing pressure and fish harvest from a series of boat counts and angler interviews. The surveys are a valuable tool for managing fish populations. Creel surveys are conducted on Lake Vermilion two consecutive years out of every six years. Aerial boat counts are used in conjunction with angler interviews to make estimates of fishing pressure and fish harvest. On Lake Vermilion, creel survey is done from opening day of the walleye season through the end of September. The survey only includes boat anglers fishing during daylight hours.

There was an estimated 580,400 hours of fishing pressure on Lake Vermilion during the survey period. The fishing pressure was similar to that observed in other recent creel surveys. A large increase in fishing pressure has been noted since the first creel surveys were done in 1984 and 1985. Some of the increased fishing pressure can be attributed to the muskie fishery that has developed on the lake. In 2009, 16% of anglers interviewed were seeking muskie. About 67% of the interviewed anglers were seeking walleye, while 9% were seeking either smailmouth bass or largemouth bass.

An estimated 68,800 walleye weighing 53,900 pounds were harvested in 2009, the lowest walleye harvest observed on Lake Vermilion since 1996. The low walleye harvest was due primarily to poor reproduction in 2004 and 2005; and the protected slot limit which reduced harvest of larger fish, particularly on West Vermilion. The walleye harvest was well below the safe harvest target of 65,000 pounds for Lake Vermilion. Safe harvest targets were established for lakes in the Large Lake Program in 1996 to help protect walleye populations in these lakes. The walleye harvest in 2002 and 2003 was well above the safe harvest target, which resulted in the special regulation that began in 2006. An additional 47,000 pounds of walleye would likely have been harvested if the 17-26 inch protected slot had not been in place, pushing the harvest well above the safe harvest target. The walleye harvest included an estimated 3,200 pounds of release mortality and 1,400 pounds of fish that were in the protected slot and illegally harvested. An estimated 181,853 walleye were caught and released during the survey period. Fishing success for walleye varied widely between East Vermilion and West Vermilion in 2009. The walleye harvest on East Vermilion was near average, while the harvest on West Vermilion was one of the the lowest ever observed. Poor walleye fishing on West Vermilion was due primarily to poor reproduction in 2004 and 2005. In addition, the 2006 year class is stronger on East Vermilion, which resulted in better fishing on that lake basin.

An estimated 3,600 northern pike weighing 7,500 pounds were harvested during the survey period, the lowest pike harvest ever documented on Lake Vermilion. Northern pike harvest is restricted by the special regulation that was implemented in 2003. Harvest of northern pike had been declining even before the special regulation went into effect. Declining harvest prior to 2003 may have been related to increased catch and release fishing and fewer anglers targeting northern pike. An estimated 31,900 northern pike were caught and released.

An estimated 4,300 smallmouth bass weighing 7,300 pounds were harvested in 2009, similar to harvests in 2003 and 2008. Harvest of smallmouth bass had been declining prior to 2003, but has increased in recent surveys, probably because of higher abundance. An estimated 39,700 smallmouth bass were caught and released.

An estimated 950 largemouth bass weighing 1,900 pounds were harvested during the survey period, similar to harvests in other recent surveys. Largemouth bass are more abundant in West Vermilion and most of the harvest came from that lake basin. An estimated 21,700 largemouth bass were caught and released.

No harvested muskie were encountered during the survey, producing a harvest estimate of zero fish. It is known that a few muskie are harvested each year, although that number is believed to be quite low. An estimated 1,600 muskie were caught and released, slightly below the catch in 2008. Many muskie are caught at night and during late fall; and these fish are not documented during the survey. The largest muskie reported during the survey was 53 inches long.

An estimated 8,300 black crappie weighing 5,700 pounds were harvested in 2009, slightly above harvests observed in other recent surveys. Crappie are more abundant in West Vermilion and most of the harvest came from that lake basin. An estimated 4,400 crappie were caught and released.

The bluegill harvest was estimated to be 14,500 fish weighing 4,800 pounds, slightly below the 2008 harvest. Most of the harvest came from West Vermilion, where bluegill are much more abundant. An estimated 51,300 bluegill were caught and released.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank Lake Vermilion anglers for their cooperation during the 2008 and 2009 creel surveys. The interview process may be a little inconvenient, however the information gained is very valuable. Creel survey clerks who have worked during our surveys were very impressed with how cooperative and friendly Lake Vermilion anglers were. That cooperation s much appreciated. I encourage anyone who has questions about the creel surveys to contact me or stop by our office for a visit. The DNR office is located just west of Tower on highway 169.

Duane Williams, Large Lake Specialist
MN DNR Section of Fisheries
650 Highway 169
Tower, MN 55790
Phone: 218-753-2580 ext. 224
e-mail: duane.williams@state.mn.us